Home Goods to the rescue! On Saturday, I popped in and found a large pewterish mirror for just $29.99! It's an instantly lighter, brighter look. The wooden mirror was larger overall, but the actual mirror was smaller. I couldn't even really see my reflection in it. The new mirror also reflects so much more light from the dining room.
For accessories, I kept the Target runner, and green jug vase with branches, and then added a couple metallic Williams Sonoma cookbooks, the Hobby Lobby bird I spray painted gold, and a vase we got as a wedding gift. It's filled with wine corks.
I think this Spring mantle will be around awhile:)